Sold Out -4%
Martha Stoumen

Nero d'Avola 2016

Sale price: $43.95 Regular price:$45.95
Enter your email address below to be notified when this product is back in stock.
Tasting notes

This is one of the only Nero d'Avolas made in California, and it shows a profile you won't find in Sicily: bright, almost electric acidity alongside dark fruit and cocoa, kept fresh by the dry-farmed benchland sites in Ukiah. The 2016 comes from what is likely the oldest Nero d'Avola planting in the state at Fox Hill, with cuttings propagated to Benson Ranch in 2004, giving this wine a singular sense of place and vine history.

BodyFruitTanninAcidity
Taste profile
BlackberryBlack CherryEarthLicorice
  • Style: Dry, medium-bodied red; dark wild fruit with bright acidity and dusty tannins; 13% ABV; 516 cases
  • Grapes & Terroir: 100% Nero d'Avola; 70% Benson Ranch (head-trained, dry-farmed, gravelly loam, Ukiah) + 30% Fox Hill (Talmage Bench, sandy loam, oldest Nero d'Avola in CA, planted 1986); organic farming
  • Winemaking: Destemmed; native yeast fermentation in small vats; twice-daily punchdowns; pressed at dryness; neutral barrel aging; minimal sulfites at bottling; unfined, unfiltered
  • Serving: Serve at 62-65F; decant 45 minutes if drinking young
  • Pairing: Braised lamb, roasted eggplant, pasta with wild mushrooms, aged sheep's milk cheese
  • Similar To: For fans of structured Sicilian reds like COS or Occhipinti who want a California take on the grape

Martha Stoumen's 2016 Nero d'Avola is sourced from two Ukiah-area vineyards with a direct familial connection: Fox Hill Vineyard (30%) on Talmage Bench, planted in 1986 by viticulture pioneer Lowell Stone and widely considered the oldest Nero d'Avola planting in California, and Benson Ranch (70%), planted in 2004 using cuttings taken directly from Fox Hill vines. The Nero d'Avola at these two sites shares the same genetic lineage, separated by 18 years of vine age.

Benson Ranch is a 5-acre leased site farmed by Martha Stoumen to organic principles: no pesticides, herbicides, or synthetic fungicides, with only elemental sulfur dust applied occasionally for mildew control. The vines are head-trained and dry-farmed on gravelly loam benchland soils, forcing deep root growth. Fox Hill, a 150-acre ranch with 60 acres planted to grapes, olives, and fruit trees, is farmed conventionally but without herbicides including glyphosate.

In the cellar, the fruit was destemmed and fermented with native yeast in small vats, with twice-daily punchdowns until dry, typically over about two weeks. The wine was pressed and transferred to neutral barrels on lees. Only minimal sulfites were added at bottling. Total SO2 at bottling was 12 mg/L for the comparable 2017 vintage. 516 cases were produced.

The result is a wine with bright acidity and soft, dusty tannins alongside dark wild forest fruits, cocoa, and a savory undercurrent. Nero d'Avola's ability to retain acidity in warm inland climates makes it an ideal variety for the Ukiah benchlands, where Mediterranean-style summers allow low-input farming while preserving freshness in the finished wine.

The bright acidity and savory undercurrent make this a natural match for braised lamb, roasted eggplant with tomato, or pasta with wild mushrooms and herbs. It holds up well against aged sheep's milk cheeses. Decant for at least 45 minutes if opening young.

Wine details

Dry/Sweet:, Dry
Wine Type:, Red Wine
Wine Style:, Medium Body
Grapes:, Nero d'Avola
Farming:, Organic
Vintage:, 2016
Alcohol:, 13%
Country:, United States
Region:, Mendocino County
Appellation:, Mendocino County
Bottle Size:, 750ml
Sugar Level:, Zero Added Sugar

We will process and ship your order in 2-3 business days, you will receive a shipping confirmation email with tracking as soon as the Carrier scans the shipping label.

Ground shipping time depends on location, here's a breakdown:

West Coast: 1-2 business days
Midwest: 3-4 business days
East Coast: 5 business days

Process time is not shipping time. Shipping time starts from the days successive to the day of shipping, after the order has been processed.

See here our shipping policy.


Important Compliance Requirements

FedEx and other carriers we might occasionally use can only deliver wine to customers who are 21 years or older. Someone must be at the address to receive the package, carriers don't just drop a package and leave. They must ensure the person receiving the wine is 21 or older.


Re-shipping a Package

If a package is returned to us after three failed delivery attempts, we can only re-ship the wine upon payment of a re-shipping fee, to be determined based on the shipping address and number of bottles. Shipping wine is extremely expensive. We are sorry about this, but we have no other choice. Please make sure there's always someone at the address you enter as your shipping address.

If you'd like to receive a refund for a package that was returned to us after FedEx made three delivery attempts, we can do that but we must keep a $20 refund fee; FedEx charges us a lot of money for returns, unfortunately, I can't stress this enough.


Re-routing a Package

If you'd like to reroute a package after it's been shipped, we can do so for a $20 re-routing fee. We cannot re-route a package across state borders. For any change of address, please contact us as soon as possible, ideally within 1-2 days from placing the order or we cannot guarantee we'll be able to reroute or change your order's shipping address.


Canceling an Order

If you'd like to cancel an order after it's been shipped, we can do so upon payment of a small cancellation fee – the amount depends on the size of the order. Carriers charge us a lot of money to recall a package en-route.


Heat/Frost damage

We are not responsible for heat- or frost-related issues. We offer ice-packs upon request. Please let us know if you think that there could be heat-related issues. If we don't hear anything from you regarding weather issues before an order is shipped, or if you don't request a hold due to the weather, we are not responsible for heat/frost damage.


Placed an order. What next?

1. You will receive an order confirmation email with your order summary.*

2. As soon as your order ships from the warehouse, usually within 2-3 business days, this applies to all shipping rates, you will receive a shipping confirmation email with your tracking information. 2DAY shipping refers to shipping time; we still need 2-3 business days to prepare an order. We need to pick and pack, QA, add printed collateral, and palletize the orders.

3. Please track your package using the tracking service.

4. The carrier will attempt delivery a maximum of 3 times. After 3 delivery attempts, your package will be sent back to our warehouse.**

*Please ensure your email address is correct; otherwise, you will not receive the order and shipping confirmation emails.

**If delivery is attempted 3 times without success, or if you fail to retrieve your package from the carrier depot by the stated deadline, the shipping fee will not be refunded to the customer.

Returns Policy

If you are not satisfied with your purchase, please contact us at (424) 414-2040 or via e-mail at hello@primalwine.com between 9 am and 5 pm Pacific Standard Time, Monday through Sunday, we would like to understand and try to solve your concerns. We can offer refunds only as store credit.

Producer profile

Martha Stoumen

Martha Stoumen founded her eponymous winery in 2014 in Sebastopol, Sonoma County, after completing a master's degree in Viticulture and Enology at UC Davis and a series of apprenticeships spanning the Mosel (Heymann-Löwenstein), Languedoc (Léon Barral), Marlborough (Seresin), and Sicily (COS, under Giusto Occhipinti). She also worked as assistant winemaker at Broc Cellars in Berkeley until 2017. Her label focuses on Mediterranean grape varieties grown in warm inland California valleys, particularly the Ukiah area of Mendocino County.

Stoumen leases and farms roughly 25% of her production vineyards herself, with the remainder sourced from multi-generational family growers who share her commitment to low-input farming. Her farming approach centers on dry-farming, composting over synthetic fertilizers, and encouraging predatory insects rather than applying pesticides. At Benson Ranch, she uses only elemental sulfur dust for mildew control, applied by foot with a backpack duster to minimize soil compaction. Vines are head-trained to allow cross-cultivation in both row directions.

In the cellar, Stoumen adds nothing prior to fermentation. Native yeast drives all fermentations in small concrete tanks or open-top vats, with twice-daily punchdowns until dryness is reached, typically in about two weeks. Wine is pressed and transferred to neutral barrels on lees, racked once after 12 months, then returned to barrel for a total aging period. Minimal sulfites are added only at bottling, with total SO2 kept very low across all wines. Wines are not fined or filtered.

Wine region

Mendocino County, United States

Mendocino County sits roughly 100 miles north of San Francisco and is one of California's most geographically diverse wine regions, spanning from the cool Anderson Valley appellation near the Pacific coast to the warm, dry inland valleys around Ukiah and Redwood Valley. Ukiah, where both Fox Hill and Benson Ranch are located, sits at around 630 feet elevation in the broad Russian River Valley floor and its surrounding benchlands. The benchlands above the valley floor feature well-drained gravelly and sandy loam soils deposited by ancient river activity, and the Mediterranean climate there brings hot, dry summers with little to no rainfall from May through October.

Mendocino County contains 17 AVAs, including Redwood Valley, Mendocino Ridge, and the cooler Anderson Valley. The inland benchland areas around Ukiah have historically attracted Italian immigrant farming families who planted Mediterranean grape varieties on the poorer uplifted soils, reserving the richer valley floor for vegetables. This tradition directly informs Martha Stoumen's sourcing strategy. The region is also notable for being one of California's most organically farmed wine counties by percentage of total vineyard acreage.

Frequently asked question

We will process and ship your order in 2-3 business days, you will receive a shipping confirmation email with tracking as soon as the Carrier scans the shipping label.

Ground shipping time depends on location, here's a breakdown:

West Coast: 1-2 business days
Midwest: 3-4 business days
East Coast: 5 business days

Process time is not shipping time. Shipping time starts from the days successive to the day of shipping, after the order has been processed.

See here our shipping policy.

Signature on delivery is mandatory for wine deliveries. Please make sure someone is at the shipping address to sign for the package.

If applicable, please consider delivering the package to a business address to ensure someone is available to sign for the package.

We also have the option of delivering the package to a Carrier's store for pickup. Please reach out to us to coordinate.

Carrier will try to delivery a package up to three times before returning the package to us.

See here our shipping policy.

If you miss a delivery and a package gets returned to us we have two options:

1) Reship the package right away: due to the very high cost of shipping and returns, we must charge a re-shipping fee to be determined based on package size and shipping destination.

2) Consolidate the returned package with your next order: this option is free of charge and it's the most popular option.

See here our shipping policy.

This collection features our best selling natural wine from all around the world. It's the best place to start you natural wine journey! Browse one of the largest selections of natural wine available online in the United States.

Primal Wine Natural Wine Club is the best way to discover natural wine. Let us do the heavy-lifting, sit back, and relax. We will send you an ever-changing selection of natural wine made by top producers from around the world.

Our customers love Primal

I'm just copying and pasting from the hundreds messages we received, no pseudo reviews!
Erin C.

We love our membership so far and can't wait until our next shipment.

Jennifer B.

A note to say that we are loving the tasting notes sheet you’re sending!

James S.

I'm really happy to find Primal – your selections are terrific. 

Samuel M.

Love your company, always a great wine selection. 

Chelsea V.

I love what you guys do!

What Is | Primal Wine

What is natural wine?

Natural wine is a type of wine made in small batches from organic or biodynamic grapes with minimal intervention.
What Is Biodynamic Wine Info Cards | Primal Wine

What is Biodynamics?

Biodynamic wine is wine made from grapes farmed biodynamically. Biodynamic farming is a holistic approach.
What Is Organic Wine Info Cards | Primal Wine

What is organic wine?

Organic wine is made with grapes farmed organically. Organic farming is an alternative to conventional farming.
What Is Vegan Wine Info Cards | Primal Wine

What is vegan wine?

Vegan wine is wine made without using animal products during the fining phase of the clarification process.